Cite this asPapalia T, Greco R (2020) A new litholytic therapy for nephrolithiasis. Arch Clin Nephrol 6(1): 035-037. DOI: 10.17352/acn.000046
Background and aims: Nephrolithiasis is a widespread disease and it is the most frequent cause of hospitalisation within the urological field. Medical therapy has recently evolved in correcting lithogenous processes and prompting lytic and expulsive processes. Nowadays, among new litholytic drugs, there are phytotherapeutical agents such as the aqueous extract of Phyllantus niruri (Pn). The aim of our study was to evaluate the efficacy of new therapeutic protocols in a youth population affected by Nephrolithiasis.
Methods: We evaluate 40 patients (24 females and 16 males), average age 23, affected by nephrolithiasis. All of 40 patients were randomized to take either a Phillantus niruri extract 2 gm/daily (n. 20), or placebo (n. 20, control group) for 3 months.
Results: After 3 months of therapy in the treated group the stone free patients were about 65% while in the control group the stone free patients were about 20%. Moreover we observed that Pn intake reduced urinary calcium in 10 hypercalciuric patients. During the Pn treatment none of the patients has suffered from strong colic pain and there have not been drop-outs.
Conclusions: In our experience the Pn represents an effective alternative to treatment and/or prevention of urolithiasis, although the acting mechanism is not clear. The drug has proven easy to handle, non toxic and cheap.
Urolithiasis is a widespread disease and represents the most frequent cause of hospitalisation within the urological field in western countries [1,2]. The prevalence of nephrolithiasis varies between 5 and 10% and the yearly incidence is about 0,1-6% in the world population .
Over the last 20 years the management of this disease has changed radically. The medical therapy has experienced an evolving role in urolithiasis treatment by correcting lithogenous processes and active expulsion of the stone [4-6].
Nowadays, among new litholytic drugs, there is a phytotherapeutical agent such as the aqueous extract of Phyllantus niruri (Pn) .
Pn is a plant belonging to the Euphorbiaceae family, which is so widely distributed, both in many tropical and subtropical countries, and it is generally used in Brazilian folk medicine for the treatment of urolithiasis . Moreover Pn shows antispasmodic and relaxants effects on many contractile tissue. These effects might also occur in urethral smooth muscle and might contribute to the elimination of smaller calculi .
The aim of the study was to evaluate the efficacy of Pn in young patients affected by renal stones of size < 10 mm.
From January 2009 to June 2012 we prospectively evalueted 40 outpatients affected by nephrolithiasis. The kidney stones were documented by renal ultrasound scan. Patients of both groups presented caliceal and pelvis stones. None of the patients showed hydronephrosis.
All the 40 patients started a high water intake (about 2000 cc of water/day) and a hyposodic diet (3 gr/day) . Moreover, randomly 20 patients (12 females and 8 males, average age 23±14 ) were treated with Pn ( 2 gm/day if body weight was less than 50 Kg and 4 gm/day if body weight was over 50 Kg) and the others 20 patients (12 females and 8 males, average age 20 ±12) were treated with placebo (control group), for 3 months (Table 1). We applied the student test t to compare the two populations. Urinary and blood electrolytes (calcium, phosphorus, potassium, sodium, magnesium, uricaemia), creatinine clearance, urinalysis, urine culture were determined at baseline and at the end of the study. At the beginning of the study the average stone size was 8 mm (range 4,7 to 11,2 mm) in treated group and 7,41 mm (range 4,5 to 10,1 mm) in the control group (p 0,52), Figure 1.
Both groups (treated group and control) underwent ultrasound scan after 3 months. The ultrasound scan was made by the same ultrasound physician, blinded to the treatment arm of the patients.
We observed, in treated group, n.13 patients (65%) became stone-free while in the control group only n.4 patients (20%) became stone free (p<0.001). In treated group n. 10 patients were hypercalciuric and n. 3 patients had normal calciuria. A stone-free condition was defined as the absence of any stone or residual fragments less than 3 mm. Among examined patients there have not been dropouts. None of the patients suffered by strong colic pain during Pn therapy, while 5 patients within the control group reported colic pain during the 3-months-period.
In the treated group n.10 patients (50%) were hypercalciuric. After Pn therapy the hypercalciuric patients showed a significant reduction in the mean urinary calcium (6.2±0.9 vs 3.8±0.9 mg/Kg/day, p<0.005) (Table 2). In the control group n.5 hypercalciuric patients (25%) have not presented the same result (6,0±1,1 vs 5,74±0,8 mg/Kg/day, p 0.69). Moreover, in the treated group there were no significant differences in the others mean values of urinary and blood parameters before and after Pn intake (Table 3).
The formation of kidney stones is a relatively complex process [10-12]. Generally, urine contains a certain amount of chemical agents that take part to crystal formation or precipitation. The balance among inhibitors and promoters prevents the formation of kidney stones [10-13]. A crystal forms when molecules able to create a crystal system such as calcium-oxalate, calcium-phosphate, uric acid, and cystine reach a concentration allowing them to aggregate (calculus nucleation) [10-15]. Moreover urine contains agents such as glycosaminoglycans, uroporfirine, nephrocalcine, magnesium and citrates that are able to inhibit over-saturation and crystallisation [16,17]. Therefore, the over-saturation of solutes, the reduced excretion of citrates, the decrease in urinary volume, pH changes and urinary anomalies all are potential factors in lithogenesis. Litholytic therapy represents an highly effective treatment for the urolithiasis’ promoting factors [3,18]. New therapeutic aids include the use of phytotherapy agents such as Pn [7,19].
In our study we report the results of a Pn therapy in 20 patients suffering from nephrolithiasis. Compared to the control group, these patients have shown a higher complete lithiasis clearance (stone-free) percentage.
Several authors have investigated the Pn mechanism of action. Some authors described the Pn powerful inhibitory effect on CaOX crystal adhesion and suggested that Pn intake may reduce urinary calcium in patients with hypercalciuria [19,20]. On the other hands, Freitas et al suggested that this effect was related to a higher incorporation of glycosaminoglycans into the stone, independently from urinary excretion of citrate and magnesium. In fact the calculi from Pn treated group had a higher content of GAGs, suggesting that Pn reduces the deposition of crystalline particles [10,20].
Moreover our findings have also highlighted a significant reduction in the concentration of urinary calcium in 10 patients with hypercalciuria after Pn therapy. Indeed, previous studies have assessed that Pn significantly reduces calcium urinary excretion in stone-forming patients, maybe through the significant reduction in CaOx endocytosis consequent to increase in cytosolic calcium intra or extracellular sources [19-22]. Thus Pn might prevent the internalization of CaOx crystals by changes in calcium metabolism. Instead, no control arm patient showed improvement in hypercalciuria.
Although the evidence is encouraging, the mechanism action of Pn is not totally understood. According to our experience, the drug can be a non-toxic, low-cost and effective alternative to treatment and/or prevention of urolithiasis.
Further studies are likely to provide additional confirmation of Pn efficacy in medical therapy for stone disease.
Subscribe to our articles alerts and stay tuned.