Cite this asTawiah PA, Arhin-Wiredu K, Oppong K, Torgbor BN, Konadu PE, et al. (2021) Socio-demographic characteristics influencing knowledge, attitude and preventive practices of COVID-19 among Ghanaians: A cross-sectional study. Ann Antivir Antiretrovir 5(1): 019-027. DOI: 10.17352/aaa.000012
Copyright© 2021 Tawiah PA, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Background: In recent times, the novel coronavirus disease is one of the most challenging public health burdens. Low-and-middle-income countries including Ghana have not been spared by the infection. Several measures are being undertaken by countries to control and prevent the future waves of the disease. Previous studies have established the importance of knowledge, attitude and practices towards an infection as a remedy for controlling the spread of such infection. However, further studies are required to ascertain the socio-demographic characteristics influencing the knowledge, attitude and preventive measures of COVID-19.
Methods: This study investigated the socio-demographic characteristics influencing knowledge, attitude and preventive practices towards COVID-19 among the Ghanaian population. A cross-sectional design was adopted to recruit 369 participants for the study utilizing convenience and snowball sampling methods. With the use of an electronic semi-structured questionnaire and social media platforms, an online survey was conducted from March 26 to May 1, 2020. Descriptive statistics, independent t-test, chi-square test, one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) and linear regression were used to analyze data.
Results: The average mean percentage of good knowledge, positive attitudes and good preventive practices regarding the novel coronavirus disease was 83.2%, 88.2% and 69.2%, respectively. In relation to occupation, there was significant difference (t = -2.984, p-value = 0.0030) in COVID-19 knowledge. Income level was significantly associated with attitudes towards COVID-19. Male gender (vs female, β = -1.276, p-value = < 0.00001), less than ¢500 income earners (vs above ¢1000, β = -0.845, p-value = 0.017) were associated with lower COVID-19 preventive practice score while being the 42-64 age category (vs 18–25-year group, β = 1.128, p-value = 0.028), health worker (vs non-health worker, β = 0.816, p-value = 0.001) and belonging to Ga ethnic group (vs Akan ethnic group, β = 0.89, p-value = 0.027) were associated with higher scores.
Conclusion: Although this study found higher knowledge and attitudes toward the novel coronavirus disease, it did not reflect in higher preventive practices towards the infection. In our fight against this infection in Ghana, COVID-19 preventive measure educational campaigns targeting the male gender and low-income earners should be considered and implemented.
COVID-19: Coronavirus disease 2019; GoG: Government of Ghana; ANOVA: Analysis of variance; KAP: Knowledge attitude and Practices
Since the emergence of the novel coronavirus disease (COVID-19) in December 2019 from Wuhan city in China, it has spread to many other countries around the world including those on the African continent . The World Health Organization (WHO) on January 30, 2020, declared the outbreak of the disease as a Public Health Emergency of International Concern, serving as a clarion call to the international community to provide political, financial and technical support to a public health emergency . Subsequently, COVID-19 was declared as a pandemic on March 11, 2020, due to its widespread across the globe .
In Ghana, the Ministry of Health (MOH) in a release on March 12, 2020, announced the first two confirmed cases of COVID-19 . After the pronouncement of these initial cases, the Government of Ghana (GoG) put in place numerous measures including the closing of borders, schools, churches, mosques and ban of all social gatherings . Citizens were also advised by GoG to practice precautionary measures such as the washing of hands with soap, sanitizing, social distancing among others. Notwithstanding, as of May 1, 2020, Ghana was among the top African countries that had recorded most cases of COVID-19 with 2074 confirmed cases, 212 recoveries and 17 deaths .
The battle against COVID-19 by GoG and Ghanaians as a whole continued through various phases with strict measures such as partial lockdown in various parts of the country such as Greater Accra, Greater Kumasi and Kasoa Metropolis for three weeks. This was accompanied by the compulsory wearing of nose masks, particularly in the Greater Accra region. In the wake of all these measures put in place by GoG, people’s adherence to these measures are significant and is chiefly affected by Knowledge, Attitude and Practices (KAP) towards COVID-19. This is per the KAP theory [7,8].
The second wave of the COVID-19 in India can be attributed to many factors including neglect of COVID-19 proper behaviour . And it is obvious the Indians let their guards down and did not follow the protocols and guidelines of the previous wave of COVID-19. Lack of knowledge, bad attitudes and poor preventive practices towards COVID-19 among them may have also accounted for the violation of the COVID-19 appropriate behaviour. The knowledge, attitudes and practices of standard preventive measures are significant in the prevention of future waves in India and other parts of the world.
According to some studies [10,11]. Conducted during the SARS outbreak in 2003, knowledge and attitudes toward infectious diseases like COVID-19 have a causal connection with the level of panic emotion among the general population and can subsequently complicate the efforts made to prevent the transmission of the disease. So, some basic knowledge about the COVID-19 and its modes of transmission as well as basic hygiene principles to reduce the panics related to the disease and its spread is essential.
In the specific case of the COVID-19 virus, SARS-CoV-2, the routes of transmission remains a paradox . Hence, there is an urgent call globally to research to unravel these contradictory routes of transmission and other factors including demographic characteristics that may contribute to the transmission of COVID-19. These investigations are essential to inform policy, and consequently, policymakers and public health agencies may need to upgrade their precautionary approaches to disrupt all the probable modes of transmission based on new scientific evidence .
Currently, studies have been done in some countries such as China . Egypt . Iran . Kenya . On KAP towards COVID-19 among the general population. However, the situation in Ghana has not been adequately assessed, especially the investigation of socio-demographic characteristics influencing the knowledge, attitude and practices of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Given this and all the precautionary measures put in place by the GoG together with daily education on television, radio, print and social media platforms concerning COVID-19, the study investigated knowledge, Attitude and Practice towards the novel coronavirus disease among Ghanaians. It also ascertains the socio-demographic characteristics influencing the knowledge, attitude and preventive practices of the novel coronavirus disease in the country.
A cross-sectional study was conducted from 26 March to 1st May 2020. The study adopted an online survey approach among Ghanaians, due to the restricted movement imposed on Ghanaians during the COVID 19 pandemic period. Social network platforms such as WhatsApp, Facebook, Instagram and Twitter were used as the channels for reaching people to respond to the survey.
The study was conducted among Ghanaians through online social media platforms. Ghana is a West African Country bordered by the countries; Burkina Faso, Ivory Coast and Togo in the north, west and east respectively. However, the south is bordered by the Atlantic Ocean. Ghana is divided into 16 administrative regions with Accra as the national city. The population is estimated to reach 31,072,940 in the year 2020 with Akans and Christians forming 47.5% and 71.2% of the population correspondingly. The health system is manned by the Ghana Health Service offering primary, secondary and tertiary health care in various regions.
The Centre for Disease Control Epi Info Software 22.214.171.124 was used to compute the minimum sample size required for the study. An expected frequency of 50% was used mainly because there was limited study quantifying the proportion of the population with knowledge on COVID-19. With an alpha value of 5% at a confidence level of 95%, a total sample size of 384 was computed. The study assumed a non-response rate of 5%, which resulted in a total sample size of 403. However, a total of 369 respondents took part in the study, with a response rate of 91.6%. Due to the national lockdown, respondents for the study were recruited through convenience and snowball sampling methods.
• Ability to read and operate a smartphone
• Access to the internet and social media
• Eighteen (18) years and above
• Willingness to participate in the study
• Below 18 years
• Unwillingness to participate in the study
An online survey tool was designed with google forms comprising four sections. These sections included demographic characteristics, knowledge on COVID-19, attitudes and practices towards COVID 19 among the Ghanaian population. The tool was developed in the English language. The questionnaires were multiple choice and limited format. The data collection instrument was reviewed by professionals including medical officers, medical laboratory scientists, disease control officers and disease control officers to ascertain its reliability and validity. This was followed by a pretesting. The tool was shared with authors’ social contacts on WhatsApp, Facebook, Twitter and Instagram. Respondents were also encouraged to share with their networks after completing the survey.
Collected data from google sheet was exported to excel for cleaning and imported into Stata/IC 15 statistics/data analysis software for data analysis. Categorical variables were presented as frequencies and percentages. Analysis of the KAP was done using the scaler scoring method. Questions with multiple responses were assigned 1 point and 0 for unanswered questions. Other questions with three responses were assigned 0,1and 2. For each respondent, a maximum score of 22, 6 and 13 were awarded for correctly answering all questions, good attitudes and good practices in that order. Independent t-test, one-way ANOVA and chi-square test were used to analyze and compare demographic characteristics to knowledge, practices and attitude to know statistically significant variables at p values of 5%. The linear regression model was used to analyze factors associated with knowledge, attitude and practices on COVID-19.
The study received participation from three hundred and thirty-nine (369) people. Out of this, the majority, 231 (62.6%) were males. A greater number, 156 (42.3%) of participants were within the 26-33 age bracket while the least, 26 (7.1%) were in the 42-64 age category. More than half, 207 (56.1%) were not health workers. Almost all, 356 (96.5) were Christians and had attained tertiary education. Also, most, 221 (60.0%) and 215 (58.3) of study respondents earned an average income of more than ¢1000 and were Akans, respectively. Again, the majority, 123 (33.3%) respondents were residents of the Greater Accra region, this was followed by the Ashanti and Eastern region (Table 1).
The average mean of knowledge on COVID-19 among study participants was 18.3 ± 2.36 out of a maximum score of 22, showing a mean percentage of good knowledge of 83.2% (Figure 1). The correct answer rate of questions (K1-K12) relating to knowledge on COVID-19 ranged from 4.3-99.2%. However, the correct answer rate to questions (K1-K7) that required a single answer ranged from 89.4-99.2%. With regards to questions (K8-K12) that required more than one correct answer, the rate of identifying all correct answers ranged from 34.7-91.9% (Table 2).
The average mean of participant’s attitude towards COVID-19 was 5.29 ± 0.88 out of a maximum score of 6, representing a mean percentage positive attitude of 88.2% (Figure 1). The majority, 61.5% of above ¢1000 per month income earners had good attitudes towards the novel disease (Figure 2). Based on the questions to ascertain attitudes towards COVID-19, a good attitude rate ranged from 75.1-99.7%. The majority of participants (77.0%) thought it was safe to get closer to a person who has previously suffered from COVID-19. Almost all (99.7%) participants claimed it was significant to observe the health guidelines. The majority, 91.3% and 90.2% of participants did not believe COVID-19 is a spiritual disease and deception, respectively. Many, 75.1% and 95.4% of the respondents also were confident the Government of Ghana could win the battle against COVID-19, and successfully control the pandemic correspondingly (Table 3).
The average mean of COVID-19 preventive practices was 9.0 ± 2.18 out of a maximum score of 13, making up a mean percentage of the good preventive practice of 69.2% (Figure 1). Also, 60.1% of males were involved in good practices towards the novel disease (Figure 3). Most participants, 179 (48.5%) and 299 (81.0%) always wore masks and avoided crowded places, respectively. The majority of participants, 359 (97.3%) washed their hands with soap under running water; nonetheless, only one-third, 123 (33.3%) did the washing of hands more than 10 times a day. Also, a little above one-third of the participants, 130 (35.2%) disinfected their hands with alcohol-based sanitizers more than 10 times daily. Again, many of the participants admitted they sometimes touched their face, nose and mouth (Table 4).
In relation to demographic characteristics, gender was significantly (Pearson chi2 = 7.34, p-value = 0.007) associated with practices towards COVID-19, while income level of participants was also significantly (Pearson chi2 = 8.48, p-value = 0.007) associated with attitudes towards the COVID-19 pandemic (Table 5).
There was significant difference in knowledge on COVID-19 in relation to the occupation (t = -2.984, p-value = 0.0030) of study participants. Again, significant differences existed in attitudes with respect to income level (F = 4.12, p-value = 0.0169) and ethnicity (F = 4.67, p-value = 0.0032). Also, there was significant differences in practices towards the COVID-19 pandemic regarding gender (t = 4.712, p-value = 0.0001), occupation (t = -3.320, p-value = 0.0010) and income level (F = 3.25, p-value = 0.0400) (Table 6).
A multiple linear regression analysis depicted that male gender (vs female, β = -1.276, p-value = < 0.00001), income level (¢) of less than 500 (vs above 1000, β = -0.845, p-value = 0.017) were significantly associated with lower practice score (Table 7). However, 42-64 age category (vs 18–25-year group, β = 1.128, p-value = 0.028), health worker as an occupation (vs non-health worker, β = 0.816, p-value = 0.001) and belonging to an Ga ethnic group (vs Akan ethnic group, β = 0.89, p-value = 0.027) were significantly associated with higher practice score (Table 7).
This study investigated the knowledge, attitudes and practices of Ghanaians towards the novel coronavirus disease through an online survey. Averagely, participants of this study showed a high knowledge of the disease. This finding was not different from a similar study conducted among the Egyptian population . Additionally, an extremely higher mean score of knowledge was recorded in a study conducted among Chinese residents . All these results show the concern that was attached to the disease. Besides, the high COVID-19 knowledge level may also have resulted from the educational level of participants who took part in the study .
Again, our study revealed that health workers had significantly higher knowledge scores compared to non-health workers. This result is expected since health workers are the front-liners in the fight against the coronavirus pandemic. However, a study conducted by Yue et al. showed that being a health care worker had a significant impact on COVID-19 knowledge, but there was no significant difference in knowledge of health workers and non-healthcare workers . Significant differences in COVID-19 knowledge rather existed in age groups, marital status, gender and educational level .
The findings of our study depicted a high mean percentage attitude score of almost 90%. A similar result was reported in a population-based study done in Iran . Further, both recent and previous studies conducted within Africa and other parts of the world within this pandemic period have reported high positive attitudes towards the novel coronavirus disease [17-19,21]. Knowledge is usually associated with attitudes. Therefore, the high COVID-19 knowledge among participants from different countries may have influenced the general attitude of people worldwide. A study conducted in Nigeria confirms a significant relationship between COVID-19 knowledge level and attitudes towards COVID-19 preventive practices .
Earlier modelling studies had predicted the severity of the novel coronavirus pandemic globally; the severity is expected to be intense in low-income settings and among people earning low income [22,23]. In our study, we found that attitudes towards COVID-19 were significantly associated with the income level of participants. And, it was confirmed in our study that a positive attitude towards the COVID-19 was significantly higher among participants who received higher income compared to those who received lower income. Also, positive attitudes towards COVID-19 were found among the majority of above ¢1000 income earners. Therefore, it is obvious that negative attitudes among low-income earners may be the reason why the severity of the COVID-19 preventive items, such as nose masks and sanitizers.
In a study . Conducted among ethnic minorities in Hong Kong, participants expressed some misconceptions on the prevention of novel coronavirus disease; however, they had positive attitudes towards the approved preventive measures of the infection including wearing masks and social distancing. Though in our study, ethnicity was not associated with attitudes towards COVID-19, significant differences in attitude were among ethnic groups, implying that an ethnic group had better attitudes towards COVID-19 compared to the others. These findings are expected because earlier studies . Have reported a relationship between ethnicity and the spread of COVID-19. This observation suggests that the cultural and socio-economic characteristics of an ethnic group significantly affects their attitudes toward a disease; whether positive or negative.
The mean percentage of COVID-19 preventive practices in our study was found to be 69.2%. This outcome was similar to recent research in Nigeria that depicted an average percentage of 68.0% . Nonetheless, a study published after a few months of the COVID-19 pandemic revealed that over 95.0% of study participants engaged in all COVID-19 preventive practices . The discrepancies in the average practices may be due to the period, and countries where the studies were conducted. The earlier study (16) and our study were conducted in West African countries during the national lockdown, which was many months into the COVID-19 pandemic; however, the latter was conducted in the early period of the epidemic in China.
Also, in this study, practices towards the novel coronavirus were significantly associated with gender. Besides, although our study found that the majority of males were found to be involved in good practices of COVID-19, female participants significantly adhere to COVID-19 preventive measures compared to their male counterparts. The findings of this study synchronize with another, which revealed that men were associated with the lower practice of COVID-19 preventive measures, including wearing nose masks and going to crowded places . A study by Erfani et al. also confirms the high practice of COVID-19 preventive measures among females compared to males . Additionally, research . Conducted to study gender differences in COVID-19 linked beliefs and behaviour revealed that, generally, females perceived the pandemic as a serious health issue and subsequently comply with all the preventive measures compared to males. This accounts for the considerable difference in COVID-19 mortality cases between women and men.
This study found the occupation and income level of study participants to be significantly associated with COVID-19 preventive practices. As expected, health workers practiced COVID-19 preventive measures compared to non-health workers. Erfani et al. study . On COVID-19 found results similar to our study, where being a health care provider was associated with adequate knowledge, attitude and preventive practices towards COVID-19 infection. The population working in healthcare-related facilities are at the forefront of the coronavirus virus pandemic; therefore, it is highly expected of these workers to practice COVID-19 preventive measures. According to a recent Chinese study, COVID-19 preventive measures were practiced by participants who earned higher income . However, the results of this study revealed that participants who earned between ¢500-1000 as income practiced COVID-19 preventive measures compared to those who received less than 500 and above ¢1000. Furthermore, our study showed a strong association between the income level of above ¢1000 and lower practice scores. These results suggest the unpredictability of human behaviour, which may be affected by factors such as knowledge and complacency.
This study, finally, found out that being within the age category of 42-64 years and belonging to a Ga ethnic group are associated with a higher COVID-19 preventive practice score. The numerous data that churned out at the early stage of the COVID-19 pandemic revealed that the older age group were at high risk compared to the youth . So, educational and preventive campaigns were all targeted at this age bracket. This may be the reason for the higher practice score among them . The Ga ethnic group are inhabitants of Accra, the epicentre of the novel coronavirus in Ghana. In essence, it was expected that this group may adhere more to the preventive measures compared to the other ethnic groups in Ghana.
Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the study was limited to only participants who could read and write, since the survey was made available on solely social media platforms.
In summary, our research suggests that knowledge and attitudes towards novel coronavirus disease were high among the Ghanaian population; however, preventive practices towards the infection was just above average. Occupation and income level had a significant relation with knowledge and attitudes towards COVID-19 infection, respectively. Also, COVID-19 preventive practices had a significant association with gender, income level, occupation, age and ethnic group. Educational interventions on COVID-19 should be targeted towards the population involved in non-health related occupations. Good attitudes towards the pandemic should be encouraged among the low-income earners of the population. The male gender and low-income earners should be admonished to practice measures towards the curbing of the novel coronavirus disease.
Ethics approval and consent to participate: The Ghana Health Service Ethical Review Committee (GHS-ERC) guidelines and standard operating procedures exempt studies that present minimal risks such as online surveys, public behaviour observations and interviews from ethical review and clearance. Hence, the study did not require ethical approval. However, study participants’ anonymity and confidentiality were ensured since the survey did not require any identity before partaking. An informed consent section was created as part of the questionnaire to seek consent before respondents proceeded to complete the online Study Questionnaire.
The study data and materials will be provided upon request.
PAT designed the study and searched the literature. KAW, PAT and KO wrote the protocol and methods. PAT, KAW, KO, BNT, AAY, PEK designed the data collection tool and collected data. PAT, KAW and KO managed the preliminary statistical analysis and wrote the first draft of the manuscript. PAT, KAW and KO managed the final statistical analysis of the study and wrote the final manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
The authors express their utmost gratitude to all study participants who took time out of their busy schedules to complete the questionnaire for the survey hence making the study successful.
Subscribe to our articles alerts and stay tuned.